Athlete Features | Interviews

The Slow Burn: How Olivia Kerstetter and Chris Ibarra Went From Rivals to Romance

November 18, 2026 by
Credit: Courtesy of Olivia Kerstetter

When Chris Ibarra first showed up at her gym in Kansas City in 2024, Olivia Kerstetter’s first instinct was to show him who was boss.

  • “I was 18 and trying to assert my dominance over him, and show him that I was the CrossFit Games athlete, and that I’m good. So obviously, I just wanted to make sure I beat him on the workout,” Kerstetter remembers of the first time she saw Ibarra, now her boyfriend.

Things didn’t go so well for her that day. 

The workout included bench press, heavy double-unders, and toes-to-bar, “and he crushed me,” said Kerstetter, now a three-time Games veteran and podium finisher.

  • “I do remember thinking, ‘This is the Games athlete? She can’t do a double-unders,’” Ibarra, now 25, said, laughing at the memory. 

Kerstetter admitted: “It was pretty humbling for me, and I was mad that he beat me.” 

Two years later, it’s a memory the couple — who officially began dating last March — still laughs about. 

  • “It was not love at first sight,” Kerstetter said in our interview with the young couple. 

Ibarra added: “I’m not going to lie, when I first met her, I wasn’t like, ‘I want to date her.’”

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Olivia Kerstetter (@oliviakerstetter)

The Slow Burn

When Ibarra moved from Missouri to Kansas City in January 2024, he and Kerstetter quickly became training partners.

  • “When we first met, it was a training-partner, rivals kind of situation, but we both had the same goal of going to the Games, and everyone else that we worked out with didn’t have that goal, and so we would be at the gym just us two, and I feel like whenever you’re stuck in the gym together all day, you bond,” Kerstetter said.

The bonding led to banter and “talking shit,” said Kerstetter, who admitted it took some getting used to.

  • “She used to take it to heart,” Ibarra said.

Kerstetter shrugged, saying, “I used to be sensitive.

Soon, Kerstetter and Ibarra began carpooling to the gym, and a real friendship began to develop, one that even started to show hints of flirtation. 

  • “We would talk about random things…and I guess I caught feelings,” Kerstetter admitted.

Ibarra, too, started to see Kerstetter differently.

  • “The more we hung out, I was like, ‘Wow, she’s pretty fun to hang out with,’” he said. 

Despite their young age, they did the mature thing and sat with the feelings for a while before making any hasty decisions. But when their bond grew even stronger, they began openly talking about the possibility of dating. 

  • “We actually talked about it for a very long time. In my head, I was like, ‘If we date and it doesn’t work out, it’s going to be really weird,’ Ibarra said. “So we both thought about it really hard. I didn’t want to lose her as a friend.”

The ultimate question boiled down to whether they wanted to take a risk and see if dating might lead to something even greater than their friendship. 

In fairness, Kerstetter said she didn’t need a full year to think about it. She knew her answer was yes much sooner. 

Ibarra, though, needed a bit more time, but got there eventually. Last March, they made it official: They were dating.

Courtesy of Olivia Kerstetter

Life Today

Both Kerstetter and Ibarra insist that spending hours each week in the gym as romantic partners felt like a natural transition. 

  • “I feel like we have a good balance. When we’re at the gym, we talk about gym stuff, and we act like training partners. And then whenever we’re hanging out outside of the gym, we don’t talk too much about CrossFit or the gym. Chris hates to talk about training or what we have to do tomorrow,” Kerstetter said.

Ibarra added: “When she brings up training, I’m like, ‘Don’t talk to me about it right now. I’ll look at it tomorrow.”

And while they do spend a lot of time together, it’s not 24/7, as Ibarra works as a personal trainer and Kerstetter is a student studying exercise science at KU, which helps with finding the right balance, they agreed. 

  • “It’s pretty perfect. We go to the gym together, and then he goes to work, and I do all my school stuff and try to be productive, and then we usually hang out in the evenings,” Kerstetter said. 

One big change since turning their friendship into a relationship, Kerstetter admitted, has been learning to be less “selfish.”

  • “When you’re doing what we’re doing, it’s so easy to be selfish and put yourself first to be the best athlete you can be, but when you’re with someone else also going the same thing, you have to learn to also put them first. You can’t always just be like, ‘Oh, I need my sleep, recovery, nutrition the way that I want it.’ You kind of have to make sacrifices for them, too,” Kerstetter said. 

She added: “We go out to eat on a date maybe a couple times a month and, at least for me, I used to be like, ‘Eating out is so bad, it’s ruining my nutrition.’ And now I’m like, ‘Wait, it’s fine to have a date every once in a while and have a date with my boyfriend.”

Their bigger challenge is agreeing on where to go. 

“Chris just always wants to go get Mexican food, and I don’t always want Mexican,” Kerstetter said.

“We don’t always get Mexican,” Ibarra retorted.

“We do 90 percent of the time,” she said.

In all seriousness, though, Kerstetter admits she is thankful to Ibarra for introducing her to new foods she was hesitant to eat before, such as tamales and sushi. And an even bigger challenge than agreeing on where to go on a date night is agreeing on what to watch on TV.

  • “It’s our biggest struggle. I’m a show person, and I like romance, or like cute shows. And he likes movies. And there are always shooting guns. I’m trying to sit on the couch and relax, but I’m listening to gunfire,” Kerstetter laughed.

“But when she watches my movies, she actually loves them,” Ibarra chimed back. 

Kerstetter added: “Only some of them.”

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Olivia Kerstetter (@oliviakerstetter)

Looking Ahead

Next up for Kerstetter and Ibarra is spending Thanksgiving with Kerstetter’s family. Shortly after, they will fly together to Copenhagen, Denmark, for the World Fitness Project (WFP) Finals, where Kerstetter is currently seventh overall and Ibarra is sixth.

While you might think competing at such a high level side-by-side could be challenging, since it’s hard to support someone else when you’re also competing, they said they have already found a way to be 100 percent focused on their own competition while still supporting one another.

  • “When the competition weekend is going on, we know it’s just three days; lock in and don’t worry about anything else. But we do check in throughout the weekend and tell each other how each event went, and any tips or tricks we have for the other person,” Kerstetter said. 

Ibarra added: “If she goes first in an event, she’ll be like, “Hey, this is how it felt, and this is what you need to make sure you don’t do or do.” So I think it’s an advantage to be dating someone who is also competing.”

And at the end of the weekend, regardless of how it goes, they know it’ll be time to put the competition behind them and head home, not as elite athletes, but as best friends and, after taking a risk, a happy couple.

  • “She is my best friend before anything else, and now I get to do life with her, as well. I wouldn’t trade what we have for anything else, and I’m glad we took the chance, because I couldn’t imagine it any other way,” Ibarra said. 

Kerstetter added: “I cannot imagine my life without Chris, so he’s stuck with me.”