After the 2018 CrossFit Games, both Tia-Clair Toomey and Mathew Fraser moved to Cookeville, Tennessee to train together at CrossFit Mayhem alongside Rich Froning, the Mayhem Freedom Team, and all of the other top CrossFitters that pass through the Mayhem doors during the season.

On an unstoppable train: The two bellwethers are setting records left and right. Their training partnership and competitive rivalry are paying dividends for both in 2019.

  • Competing head-to-head in Miami for the Open 19.5 announcement, Fraser beats Toomey and sets the world record for 19.5, only the second time that has been done during an Open announcement (Samantha Briggs set the world record in the Open 14.5 announcement). 
  • They both won the Rogue Invitational. And in their informal competition, Fraser beat Toomey with 712 points to her 696 points.  But Toomey had four event wins to Fraser’s three.  
  • At the 2019 CrossFit Games, both won the championship with Toomey earning 1071 points to Fraser’s 984 points. But Fraser this time had more events wins with six to Toomey’s five. Click here for more details on their 2019 CrossFit Games performances.

Nearly identical careers: In their CrossFit Games careers, Toomey is just one year behind with Fraser’s first Games in 2014 to Toomey’s first in 2015. Ironically career stat-wise, Toomey right now is practically in the same position that Fraser was in at the end of the 2018 Games as illustrated in the chart below.

Career StatsMathew Fraser
After CFG18
Tia-Clair Toomey
After CFG19
Games Appearances55
Games Championships33
Games 2nd Place22
Games Podiums55
Games Average Place1.4001.400
Games Event Wins911
Most Event Wins in a Games4 (2017)5 (2019)
Games Events in “White”4336
Games Event Top 2s2919
Games Event Top 5s4235
Games Event Top 10s5450
Games Average Event Place6.8686.896
Games Events Competed6867
CFG Career Ind. Earnings*$1,130,085 $1,237,036
* Includes Games, Sanctionals, Regionals, and Open Earnings

The GOAT Conversation: With their 2019 CrossFit Games performances, Fraser has arguably moved to the front of the list for best all-time individual CrossFitter and Toomey the best female CrossFitter of all time. We have seen similar simultaneous results between two champions before with Rich Froning and Annie Thorisdottir. However, Fraser and Toomey have moved up and even surpassed both athletes in parts of the record books. See the below chart on where they both measure up in key gender-neutral all-time individual category rankings.

Career RecordsMathew FraserAll Time PlaceTia-Clair ToomeyAll Time Place
Games Appearances65
Games Championships41st (Tie)33rd
Games 2nd Place21st (Tie)21st (Tie)
Games Podiums61st52nd (Tie)
Games Top 5s61st (Tie)53rd (Tie)
Games Average Place1.3332nd1.4003rd
Games Event Wins152nd114th (Tie)
Most Event Wins in a Games6 (2019)1st5 (2019)2nd (Tie)
Games Events in “White”471st362nd
Games Event Top 2s371st193rd
Games Event Top 5s511st354th (Tie)
Games Event Top 10s633rd505th (Tie)
Games Average Event Place*6.6751st6.8962nd
Games Events Competed8067
Games Pt-Margin of Victory220 (2018)1st195 (2019)3rd
Games % of Points Earned**87.1% (2017)2nd89.3% (2019)1st
CFG Career Ind. Earnings***$1,621,1231st$1,237,0362nd
* Minimum 15 Events
** Excludes 2007 with 3 Events
*** Includes Games, Sanctionals, Regionals, and Open Earnings

While the Froning v. Fraser conversation will be going on for the foreseeable future given all of Froning’s team accomplishments, Toomey appears to have moved to the front of the list as the greatest female CrossFitter of all time. 


CrossFit Games

Tia-Clair Toomey | Mathew Fraser


Get The Newsletter

For a daily Digest of all things CrossFit. Community, Athletes, Tips, Recipes, Deals and more.


Read Next:

CrossFit Games

Oct 13, 2019 by

Staging a Sell-Out: CrossFit Events Gaining Support from Government and Tourism Bodies

It doesn’t suffice anymore to run a licensed or sanctioned event and

CrossFit Games

Oct 13, 2019 by

CrossFit Open 20.1 Livestream Numbers

Week 1 of the 10th CrossFit Open kicked off worldwide on four continents

Want More?

Subscribe to our newsletter for a five minute, daily digest of all things CrossFit.